university EXPLOITATIon AND A CALL FOR EQUITABLE LABOR

A manifesto and a department position statement meant to make visible the exploitative working conditions that faculty across ranks and program directors are subjected to by university administrations. If you use or modify this statement, please credit: Dr. Vyshali Manivannan, Dept. of English, Writing, and Cultural Studies, Pace University – Pleasantville (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0).

(In)Equitable Labor at Pace University: A Manifesto

In Fall 2026, Pace University’s upper administration removed administrative release time for special service roles, including the Writing-Enhanced Program Director and Directors of Composition positions. This release time is essential to support these programs, and enables me personally to equitably perform my directorial role as an openly disabled faculty member. While my specific situation is disability discrimination as defined by the ADA/EEOC, the removal of release time has impacted nondisabled directors as well. While this manifesto emerges from my experience as the disabled WEC director for Pace’s Pleasantville campus, it’s intended to speak for all faculty in special service roles forced to work under these exploitative labor conditions.

This is not a position statement, but a set of provocations.

How many academic cultural workers can you think of whose bodymindspirits were ground to dust by exploitative labor conditions in academia? How many do you know who once worked at Pace and were unjustly fired or forced out? How many do you know who bullied their way into positions they’re unqualified for, because they felt entitled to a course release, a stipend, a title, a platform for virtue signaling to divert attention from their neoliberal capitalist loyalties, everyday academic sadism, and bigotry? How many do you know who are abused by their colleagues or superiors?

Are you?

I intentionally use academic cultural worker here instead of faculty member or professor, seeking a term that embraces the truly disenfranchised across ranks—the faculty and staff most responsible for producing the culture of an institution; who are most overworked and least compensated financially, temporally, and materially; who are most expected to pretend to be well while constantly being thrust into situations designed to physically, cognitively, and emotionally break us (Garcia-Pena, 2022; Ahmed, 2026; Lorde, 1980; Khuc, 2024; Gill, 2014).

A term that categorically excludes faculty and administrators who never knew what this was like, or who sold their souls for security and power; who have “become part of the institution [by taking] up the task of protecting it from complaint and sometimes by complaint” (Ahmed, 2026, p. 88) and thus relentlessly defend its neoliberalist capitalist commitments yet fancy themselves progressives and advocates, as though they stand in the frontlines with us instead of handing us the shovels to dig our graves.

This is not a position statement or provocation, but a game.

Like Mimi Khuc’s (2024) use of Mad Libs to reflect on what it means to be a professor, adapted here to reflect on what it is to be an academic cultural worker at Pace.

  1. None of us are well.
  2. Scrabbling for purchase in the sinkhole left by our administration’s illogical staff cuts and wasteful expenditures on inaccurate consulting firms, property development and expansion, and administrative bloat—confronted daily by the impacts of the gutting of mission-critical programs like Composition and the Writing-Enhanced Course (WEC) program during an accreditation cycle—raw as exposed nerves in the teeth from the daily abuses of workplace bullies, of using our bodymindspirits to shield our more precarious colleagues from toxic chairs, a provost whose only care is return-on-investment, a hollow president, brigades of yes-people, and an HR department that punches down savagely enough to kill—none of us are meant to be well.
  3. The compulsorily unwell professor serves the needs of Pace by ___________.
  4. The compulsorily unwell professor pretends they are well because _________________.
  5. To succeed at Pace as a compulsorily unwell professor, you must _______________.
  6. To survive at Pace as a compulsorily unwell professor, you must ______________________.

This is a game of Russian roulette with every bullet chambered.

Academia is steeped in a predatory culture of overwork, justified by a discourse of passion and excellence that configures “passionate” and “excellent” professors as those who cheerfully and uncomplainingly immerse themselves in both compensated and uncompensated, institutionally unrecognized labor (Wright, 2017). We are paid for the job duties for which we are hired—teaching and service for non-tenure-track (NTT) faculty; teaching, research, and service and administration for tenure-track (TT) and tenured faculty—but are expected to perform unpaid, invisible labor as well.

Cognitive labor: The work of reanchoring university-wide programs like Composition and WEC that are constantly destabilized by faculty in literary studies, biology, finance, business—by deans and administrators whose cost-benefit analysis of core writing and writing-enhanced courses fails to account for the fact that our students will not otherwise receive effective writing instruction—by nearly everyone outside of writing and rhetorical studies, all of whom fail to grasp that expertise in writing pedagogy is required to teach writing.

Emotional labor: The work of subordinating our private and public feelings to institutional requirements, work that disproportionately falls on women, BIPOC, and disabled academic cultural workers and is devalued and unaccounted for in reappointment or advancement—the work of mothering entitled peers and supervisors—of shouldering the burden of allegedly voluntary uncompensated roles that are nonnegotiable for continued employment—of coping with microaggressions from and enduring collective gaslighting by entitled, sadistic peers and supervisors—of supporting and advocating for disenfranchised and traumatized students and precarious colleagues, work that is worth doing that we should not have to do.

Sisyphean labor: The work of repetition, of mind-numbingly reiterative arguments with chairs, deans, the provost’s office, the president, the board of trustees, because no one is listening or reading what you say, preferring to conflagrate the pyre beneath all our feet rather than reckon with their cognitive biases.

Icarian labor: Work intended to burn us out.

In this framework, “excellence” hinges on round-the-clock availability, rapid-fire responsiveness, and measurable outputs, while “passion” encourages self-exploitation and constant deferral to institutional demands. Self-care is subsumed into this neoliberal discourse as a means of optimizing productivity for the university instead of cultivating individual wellbeing.

A truism that is true: The university and its yes-people will never love you back.

We believe that subscribing to this discourse not only impoverishes our community but also responsibilizes and blames us for our own debilitation and death. We stand in solidarity with the NTT and adjunct faculty that comprise our programs, whose labor enables our own and whose bodymindspirits are the first to be mulched to fertilize the university’s neoliberal, capitalist aims, which definitionally exclude our students and academic cultural workers alike.

We recognize that the weight of labor accrues differently on different bodies, contingent on able-bodymindspiritedness, race and ethnicity, gender, sexuality, socioeconomic status, language, and other axes of intersectionality, and that these factors render some forms of labor injurious or impossible. We face different obstacles in doing our jobs; our bodymindspirits and personal responsibilities differently dictate our limits; and consequently, we experience, understand, and use time differently. What is a swift task for one might be painstaking work for another. Some people thrive on uninterrupted workdays and are able to meet last-minute deadlines even in states of perpetual disruption, while others require flexible schedules due to personal health, familial obligations, external teaching assignments, graduate school, or other factors.

We recognize that women, BIPOC, and disabled academic cultural workers bear a disproportionate amount of invisible labor, and that our Composition and WEC programs largely rely on contingent instructors who lack benefits and job security and are exploited, disempowered, and underpaid.

Importantly, we also recognize that minority status is not a monolith, and that there are everyday academic sadists among us who wield minority identity—or exaggerate their belonging to one—to deflect accusations of abuse.

We want all our academic cultural workers to have a seat at the table, to be comfortable occupying that seat as their whole, authentic selves without fear of censure or institutional repercussions.

We want equitable working conditions for all of us, and especially those of us who labor even to breathe, tasked with politely swallowing blood around Pace’s indifferent cutthroat blade.

Too few understand what it means to know: Your silence will not protect you (Lorde, 1980).

Thus, we declare what we’re exhorted to keep secret: Against our will, we are made hypocrites by Pace University’s recent removal of administrative release time and stipends from mission-critical, university-wide directorial roles, including those of the Directors of Composition and WEC, positions housed in our departments.

Our efforts to establish a sustainable culture of support in our classrooms, department, and university community—through cross-rank committees, alternative forms of assessment, writing instruction training, and information transparency—are being directly undermined by the Pace administration, who pay lip-service to pedagogical excellence but diminish and denounce writing expertise at every turn. Additionally, we would be remiss if we overlooked the material impacts of these cuts on our ability to equitably participate in the life of the institution, let alone perform our essential job functions.

Where do you exist in the profit margin our provost loves to emphasize? Are you profiting? Or is it your discarded corpse there in the gutter, generating their ROI?

When the Directors of Composition and WEC had the financial and temporal resources with which to do so, we collaboratively structured our programs to be socially just, to accommodate and support our students while attending to the material, lived realities of faculty who are women, BIPOC, disabled folks, caregivers, or who embody other contexts that increase precarity and being time- and energy-poor.

In our core writing program, we established scalable labor-based grading initiatives as an opportunity to create and sustain equitable, inclusive labor conditions for our faculty as well as our students. Labor-based grading contracts improve learning outcomes, eliminate time and energy expended on making sure the grade is justified and fair, and lessen the likelihood of grade contestations, freeing faculty—women, BIPOC, and disabled faculty especially—from the emotional labor associated with anxious, combative, or academically entitled students.

Our department has historically worked to ensure shared governance by inviting contingent faculty, who are often sidelined in decision-making processes, to serve on committees. At the same time, we recognize that the work of shared governance and professional development often comprises unremunerated labor that settles especially heavily on contingent faculty, women, BIPOC, disabled people, caregivers, and other identities generally denied professional power and privilege. Since compensating labor makes labor visible, we have historically offered stipends for attending our summer faculty workshops and serving on departmental committees and have supported the inclusion of forms of invisible labor in faculty annual evaluations to acknowledge what the university demands but refuses to recognize.

With the historical provision of release time for directing the WEC program, we were able to audit WEC courses to ensure compliance with national standards; review, provide feedback on, and approve new courses; train instructors in basic writing pedagogy in workshops and one-on-one sessions; offer ad-hoc synchronous and asynchronous support; innovate program materials and resources; and present our work at nationally recognized conferences.

Given that the WEC program offers approximately 250 writing-enhanced courses taught by approximately 180 instructors per year to students from all schools and colleges at Pace, it is an understatement to say that administrative release time was key to the smooth operation of this program. Without administrative release time, we are unable to materially support WEC faculty and courses, as the time that Pace has allotted to this work only extends to approving course applications and facilitating the per-semester workshop. We are also forestalled from gathering data for accreditation.

These compromises were approved by the deanery and provost in place of restoring the release time that both supported this program and my ability specifically to equitably perform my directorial role as an openly disabled faculty member.

As my ghost story demonstrates—one of many such hauntings from the margins—Pace is indifferent to these struggles, and, if anything, capitalizes on them, and justifies this tactic with discourses of passion, excellence, and neoliberal conceptions of wellness.

Another truism: If you wait until tenure to speak up, you’re unlikely to speak up at all.

My name is Vyshali. I am newly tenured as of this writing, but this is the ghost story I have been telling for years.

I am an Associate Professor of English, Writing, and Cultural Studies and the Pleasantville WEC Director. I am openly disabled with incurable conditions, some with the potential for sudden death. Despite documenting these disabilities on my date of hire as a full-time lecturer, it took me years to convince Pace that I needed ADA accommodations to equitably participate in the workplace. And since HR doesn’t comply with ADA law regarding the implementation of my ADA accommodations, I am frequently forced to disclose my disabilities to colleagues—the kind of inherently unsafe and stressful situation that the ADA is designed to prevent.

I am credentialed in writing and rhetorical studies and have worked on writing across the curriculum initiatives since prior to coming to Pace. I have taught and researched in the field for 20 years. My work is nationally recognized. This background smacks of elitism but is necessary, because in January 2026, my expertise was undermined by the uncredentialed, inexperienced interim WEC Director for New York City whose claims were supported by the then-chair of the Dyson Curriculum Committee.

After the decision to remove administrative release time from the WEC directorship, I tried everything to stay alive. I provided proof that directing WEC constitutes as much labor as chairing a department—making it a special service role that should receive release time as outlined in the Faculty Handbook—only for HR, the deans, and the provost’s office to refuse to respond to that context. I was instructed by the former Dyson deans and the associate provost for academic strategy and student success to request release time as part of my ADA accommodations. I spent hundreds more doing so. I obtained a letter from my board-certified cardiologist connecting my temporal needs, overwork, and stress intolerance to potential death—but the request for release time was still denied. Too much of a financial hardship, despite a job opening for a salaried presidential chauffeur. Or if we give release time to you, we have to give release time to everyone—a fundamental and willful misinterpretation of the ADA.

Although HR personnel have openly attested that they don’t understand the nature of academic work, they are permitted to gatekeep the resources we need to do that work.

Ultimately, I was explicitly instructed orally and in writing, by the former Dyson deans, by the associate provost for academic strategy and student success, by the tacitly approving silence of the provost, to accept an inequitable, discriminatory restructuring of my faculty job obligations that would forever preclude promotion opportunities at Pace and make me invisible in my broader academic field—or to stop doing my job.

I rejected this restructuring, but it has left me in limbo.

I can biometrically correlate these harmful, gaslighting, labor-compounding exchanges with Pace administration with poorer health outcomes. I can’t go on. The university says, to survive, by its definition of survival which puts my life—all our lives—differentially at risk: I must.

This is not a position statement, but a ghost story masquerading as one.

All of us who have been forced out. All of us who have died. All of us who remain here as the walking dead. All of us who are running out of choices and time.

What is your ghost story? Are you the spectral presence in its margins? Or is it someone else who the university has symbolically or literally killed?

If we can’t go on like this, we must not go on like this.

“The powerful already know the truth; if they’re not convinced yet, repeating it isn’t going to change anything” (Kahn, 2017, p. 262). And yet, complaints are how you show what you know (Ahmed, 2026).

We can’t ethically continue to reproduce for ourselves the structural inequities and imbalances that Pace University’s administration increasingly imposes on us and that we aim to rectify for our students with our writing initiatives. As such, we see this document as an essential companion to our Composition and WEC programs and as a valuable, critical intervention into the toxic discourse of neoliberal academic productivity. Through reconfiguring the discourse of excellence, passion, and optimized hyperproductivity to care work for our bodymindspirits in terms of equitable labor, time, differential unwellness, and authentic being, we work to both accommodate our students and make our own labor expectations explicit and bounded, normalizing invisible labor as work that deserves material reward.

We see this as a living document, drafted, edited, reviewed, and modified by academic culture workers at all ranks in writing and rhetorical studies, and open to further modification as we collaborate on developing a progressive future for labor practices in our writing programs. We hope that this philosophy and its explicit commitments begin to address the material realities faced by academic cultural workers and to call attention to the ways in which Pace University is actively hindering our ability to create a sustainable culture of writing across the university; effectively train our students to become effective communicators during college and in the workforce; and create equitable, inclusive, legally compliant working conditions for the academic culture workers directing and teaching in our university-wide writing programs.

Department Materials: EQUITABLE LABOR FOR FACULTY

If you use or modify this statement, please credit: Dr. Vyshali Manivannan, Dept. of English, Writing, and Cultural Studies, Pace University – Pleasantville (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0).

Academia is steeped in a predatory culture of overwork, justified by a discourse of passion and excellence, that exacerbates the burden of those who already speak from the margins. This discourse configures “excellent” and “passionate” professors as those who cheerfully immerse themselves in both the paid labor they agreed to—primarily teaching and assessment—and the institutionally unrecognized and uncompensated invisible labor of supporting and advocating for students, many of whom are alienated, marginalized, and even traumatized; dealing with grade contestations; coping with microaggressions and academic entitlement; negotiating departmental requests for voluntary committee work; and managing other forms of unpaid labor implicitly presented as essential for continued employment. In this framework, “excellence” hinges on round-the-clock availability, rapid-fire responsiveness, and measurable outputs, while “passion” encourages self-exploitation to meet those demands. Self-care becomes co-opted into this neoliberal discourse as a means of optimizing productivity for the university, not cultivating individual well-being.

We, the faculty of the Dept. of English, Writing, and Cultural Studies, believe subscribing to this discourse impoverishes our community. Furthermore, it would be hypocritical to ignore the conditions faced by our faculty as we use our labor-based grading contracts to establish a “culture of support” in our classrooms. Thus, we recognize that the weight of labor accrues differently on different bodies, contingent on gender, race, socioeconomic status, able-bodiedness, and other axes of intersectionality, and that these factors render some forms of labor injurious or impossible. We recognize that women and BIPOC faculty shoulder a disproportionate amount of invisible labor in academia, and that writing programs largely rely on contingent part-time instructors who lack benefits and job security and are exploited, disempowered, and underpaid. We see our labor-based grading initiative as an opportunity to create and sustain equitable, inclusive labor conditions for our faculty as well as our students.

We developed our labor-based grading contracts to accommodate and support our students, but it is a system that is also considerate of the material, lived realities of faculty who are women, BIPOC, disabled folks, caregivers, or who embody other contexts that increase precarity or demand time and energy. We face different obstacles in doing our jobs; our bodies and personal responsibilities differently dictate our limits; and consequently, we experience, understand, and use time differently. What is a swift task for one might be painstaking work for another; where some have uninterrupted workdays and are able to meet even last-minute deadlines, some require flexible schedules due to familial obligations, personal health, external teaching assignments, graduate school, or other factors. The work of preparing for courses, giving feedback, and assigning grades is arduous and time-intensive, and we attempt to accommodate multiple forms of time perception and management and to restore free time. For instance, labor-based grading contracts lessen the likelihood of grade contestations, thus freeing faculty—women or BIPOC professors especially—from the emotional labor associated with anxious, combative, or academically entitled students. Labor-based grading also eliminates time and energy expended on making sure the grade is justified and ranking student papers so the grading seems fair.

We want all our professors to have a seat at the table and be comfortable occupying that seat as their whole, authentic selves, without fear of censure, institutional repercussions, or being deemed less capable of academic work. We therefore work to ensure shared governance by inviting contingent faculty, who are often sidelined in decision-making processes, to serve on committees. At the same time, we remain sensitive to the fact that labor accrues most on those who are most disenfranchised. We respect that people are not always able to take on extra labor or meet inflexible deadlines without detriment to themselves, and that not all faculty members can perform the same duties or complete work in the same span of time. Furthermore, we recognize that the work of shared governance and professional development often comprises unremunerated labor that settles especially heavily on contingent faculty, women, BIPOC, disabled people, caregivers, and other identities generally denied professional power and privilege. Since compensating labor makes labor visible, we offer stipends for attending our summer faculty workshops and serving on departmental committees, and we strive to finance other forms of invisible labor as the departmental budget permits, evidenced most recently by contingent faculty having conference fees paid for by the Department of ENG & MLS and Dyson College. At minimum, we support the inclusion of some forms of invisible labor in faculty annual evaluations. While providing yearly self-assessment is in fact additional labor, we feel that such an approach allows for a more equitable review of your teaching commitments.  

We can’t ethically continue to reproduce for ourselves the structural inequities and imbalances we aim to rectify for our students with our labor-based grading contracts. As such, we see this labor statement for faculty as an essential companion to our labor-based grading contracts, and as a valuable intervention into the problematic discourse of neoliberal academic productivity. Through reconfiguring the discourse of excellence, passion, and productivity to labor, bodies, time, and authentic being, we work to both accommodate our students and make our own labor expectations explicit and bounded, normalizing invisible labor as work that deserves material reward. We hope that this philosophy and its explicit commitments begin to address the material realities faced by our faculty members and to continue restoring equity in our program.

We see this as a living document, drafted, edited, reviewed, and modified by members of our department at all ranks, and open to further modification as we collaborate on developing a progressive future for labor practices in our writing program. Feedback is welcome and encouraged.

REFERENCES

Ahmed, S. (2026). No! The art and activism of complaining. The Feminist Press at CUNY.

Garcia-Pena, L. (2022). Community as rebellion: A syllabus for surviving academia as a woman of color. Haymarket Books.

Gill, R. (2014). Academics, cultural workers and critical labour studies. Journal of Cultural Economy, 7(1): 12-30.

Kahn, S. (2017). The problem of speaking for adjuncts. In S. Kahn, W. Lalicker, & A. Lynch-Biniek (Eds.), Contingency, exploitation, and solidarity: Labor and action in English composition. WAC Clearinghouse.

Khuc, M. (2024). dear elia: Letters from the Asian American abyss. Duke University Press.

Lara, I. (2002). Healing sueños for academia. 
In G. Anzaldúa & A. Keating (Eds.), this bridge we call home: radical visions for transformation. Routledge. 

Lorde, A. (1980). The cancer journals. spinsters.

Wright, A. (2017). The rhetoric of excellence and the erasure of graduate labor. In S. Kahn, W. Lalicker, & A. Lynch-Biniek (Eds.), Contingency, exploitation, and solidarity: Labor and action in English composition. WAC Clearinghouse.